The Emperor, y’know, has no clothes

Individualists who’ve been at the internet debate thing for a while will tell you: in taking on their ideological enemies (i.e., collectivists) in wars of words, the hardest thing to get is an unabashed, brutally honest statement of their position.

Last Friday evening John Stossel did a “Give Me A Break” segment that questioned the use of government to fund stem-cell research, i.e., compelling you to pay taxes and then using that money to fund something you may or may not agree with. Ron Alridge delivers that rare, naked glimpse of collectivism that’s not often seen.

“Dear John: I am a former TV critic (“Chicago Tribune”, “Charlotte Observer”) and former publisher/editorial director of a leading TV industry trade (“Electronic Media”) and I therefore consider myself to be a somewhat astute observer of television journalism. With that said, your recent rant against state funding for stem cell research in California was pandering, ideologically driven journalism at its worst…you just kept whining (you DO whine, you know) about the horror of using “taxpayer” money to fund stem cell research … It was an embarrassing display of shallowness and stupidity at a high level of American journalism. John, let’s give you a little Civics 101 lesson. See, government, by necessity, often takes on projects that are costly and that serve the greater public interest. That’s more or less why we have government, in fact. Just because a whiny, middle-aged network journalist would rather buy another pair of Gucci loafers with “his” tax money doesn’t give him the right to opt out of projects that he personally doesn’t like…I don’t like war, but I don’t advocate allowing us antiwar types to prevent the government from spending tax dollars to maintain an army … Such thinking represents a myopic, woefully ignorant view of the workings of a democracy. Much as it makes you so mad that you could spit and stomp, you can’t always have your way in a democracy, John. It’s not all about you or your Yuppie neighbor or the Bush Davidians with the Republican sign in their yard down the street. Your view or my view doesn’t always prevail. The overarching point is that all of us must abide, more often than not, by the will of the majority. For you to suggest that any such example of majority rule can become “tyranny of the majority” is absurd … John, allow me to let you in on a little secret about “your” tax dollars. Pssst, they aren’t YOUR tax dollars. They never were. From the minute you punched in on the job, those dollars were the property of whatever governing body was entitled to them by law. You never EARNED that money. It was the price you paid for the privilege of working. It’s just that the government gave you a break by not collecting in advance…You made yourself and your network look bad with your Friday night rant. It was childish, shallow and ignorant…
Didn’t they teach you anything at Princeton? I’m beginning to suspect that my late, Yale-educated friend and colleague, Gene Siskel, wasn’t joking when he called Princeton a college “for kids with money and no brains.” OK, that was ugly. But I enjoyed writing it. The truth is that the private sector is often a woefully inferior alternative to government, your libertarian ideology notwithstanding.” — Ron Alridge

Of course, the best thing about a display such as this is that I don’t need to take any time to uncover the hidden premises. In this case, he’s opened them wide up for everyone to see.

Richard Nikoley

I'm Richard Nikoley. Free The Animal began in 2003 and as of 2021, contains 5,000 posts. I blog what I wish...from health, diet, and food to travel and lifestyle; to politics, social antagonism, expat-living location and time independent—while you sleep—income. I celebrate the audacity and hubris to live by your own exclusive authority and take your own chances. Read More

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow by Email8k