When Do You Get Cancelled?
I have a low regard for that quote for the simple reason I’ve seen it breathlessly posted for decades as though it’s some new discovery or insight, when the simple fact is that nobody gives an eff, really.
I suppose it’s the same sort of psychology of not paying too much regard to accident scenes with mangled human bodies strewn all over, because that’s the shit that happens to other people.
The bromide I’ve always prefered is the one where the power to burn the books you don’t like is the same power to burn your Bibles.
This all speaks to operating by principles but the so-called principled actors—Republicans, conservatives, religious—only give lip service to their core principles. They have little choice. While most can respect another’s religious or core beliefs, it’s hard to take seriously stuff like God said or The Bible says.
1 – In any conflict between two men (or two groups) who hold the same basic principles, it is the more consistent one who wins.
2 – In any collaboration between two men (or two groups) who hold different basic principles, it is the more evil or irrational one who wins.
“The Anatomy of Compromise,” Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal, Ayn Rand, p. 145; bold emphasis mine for differentiation
We’ve been watching that play out since 1917 globally. The above was written many decades ago. Do note that capitalism has zero to do with statutory and/or publicly traded corporations. That’s corporatism, i.e., fascism, properly defined—an alliance and partnership between state and big business. Does that ring a bell?
The difficulty of the political right and left being at odds principally, is that the former loses credibility when they admit their principles come from God or The Bible—no matter how good and decent they may be in practice (a gulf libertarians have always tried to bridge)—and the latter gains credibility when asserting that their principles are based on The Science!—no matter how awful in practice and no matter how much counter-science there is.
This has been going on for a hundred years, since the Bolshevik Revolution.
And having gained such permeation throughout all of global society over the last 50 years, the tide has even turned on moral grounds such that we now witness an hilarious spectacle where the left doesn’t need to talk about science so much anymore—they can exercise moral condemnation, which used to be the stock in trade of the right.
That sort of thing has been subtle and nuanced over decades but since Trump in 2016, has fully reared its head to where gradually, the right is trying to bring the better science to bear; whereas, the left is screaming don’t kill my gramma you evil euthanasiaists.
So, over the last couple of years:
- Anti-mask (you’re Hitler)
- Anti-lockdown and house arrest (you’re Stalin)
- Anti forced experimental drugs (you’re Pol Pot)
In the wide swaths of histories and in my calmer moments, I can see how that’s a gift. Call me whatever you like. Since that’s not me, nor anyone I know, the chances are that the haunting won’t be on me.
Oh Lord, calm my soul.
Then the other pretty simple thing is the realization and understanding that this is less about righteous moral outrage—which righties understand well—and more about gratuitous outrage couched in moral parlance…along with all the tools available by the internet and social media to practice it on a global scale. Your thoughts matter to everyone in the world, so you tell them. It used to be that only mom and dad would give you an audience to vent childish tantrums. They understood how to tolerate them but today, that’s unsatisfying and so the whole world gets it, and sadly, there exists too many in the same boat. Those are all your Likes. Lots of them.
The left is nothing if not politically clever and has been running circles around the right for decades. The right has always been so inept and compromising that the left, now, holds all the “moral” high ground.
And make no mistake. The right has always been about cancelling people. Always. Since the fucking Spanish Inquisition. What goes around comes around. The left is simply showing how much better they can do it. And it’s not a Come To Jesus thing.
There are signs that the left has pushed the pendulum so far in one direction that it might swing the other way. Midterm elections will be the tell tale and I’m quite optimistic, especially in local and state elections.
…But the biggest unknown now is the shift in narrative from how evil those opposed to any measures “against” Covid were evil grandma killers, to how now all Russians are evil conquistadores—even Russian cats, if you caught wind of that hilarity. Or even if so, you’re allowed another belly laugh.
I suppose that in some ways I’m undercutting my own thesis by showing the ridiculousness and hilarity of it all but here’s what I would say.
Those with religious dispositions have always had a tough row to hoe, in spite of whether their religious and ancient scriptural values are actually practically effective (and I’m in full agreement that many are). You simply aren’t going to prosthelytize the majority of the world to your beliefs. It’s not that they’re anti-science, it’s that they disregard science. Religious people do respect science, and good on them for that, but only up to a point where it conflicts with ancient scriptures and faith. That is and will always be a total non-starter in modern practical politics.
On the other hand, moral proclamations are very powerful and influential in the social and political sphere and so the left has gradually, over decades, shown how best to co-opt and use that. By basing it on “science.”
Was has really taken place since secularism was possible for individual thinkers—meaning no particular belief or allegiance—is the recognition that humans are not evolved enough to function well that way. They seemingly need a cause. Religion always filled that role and in many ways did a fine job for families and local communities. You could take your pick because each of them were exemplars of good families and communities. From a bird’s eye view, doctrine and scriptural differences aren’t important.
People think that’s an issue of the right but it’s even more pronounced amongst the left. The right relies upon scripture and faith, admittedly (even implying an understanding of its limits); the left relies upon science. But they do so using words like settled science (the same as scripture) and denier (same as heathen, infidel, and blasphemer). This is fundamentalist religion by other means.
Science seeks truth. It never ever gets there. It only gets closer when done properly. In this sense, the right and honestly religious have not been much of a threat to scientific discovery in a long time. The Catholics were superstars in that vein. By contrast, the left has been the driving corruptive force for decades and from what I see, large swaths of science are nothing more than religious text now, and people fight over doctrinal interpretations they call a new study.
It’s all still a wholly moral play and always has been.
Their 2-year extravaganza of scouring social-media posts for signs of evil in terms of Covid…so they can jump on the bandwagon with a me too—like Praise The Lord breaking out during a revival—the Covid nonsense is on death’s door, so what’s the next bandwagon?
THE RUSSIANS!!!
I guess since that’s a proven hoax in terms of Trump—though few seen to know and acknowledge that—it’s ripe for a revival and so disappointment turns to rejuvenation. I don’t know. I’ve always found it curious how the the left wing that was so enamored over the Soviet Union for decades has, for about 7 years now, been so judgemental of Russia.
It’s an honest mystery to me. Russia, in spite of its large landmass and natural resources has done very poorly in terms of development over the last 30 years. Why not encourage and help where you can in getting them to world class status? They are the 2nd nuclear power to the USA. Do people forget this? Wouldn’t you want a very stable, secure, and prospering Russia and use politics and diplomacy to hold back the biggest threat in all of human history…communist/fascist and authoritarian China…the nation and race of ants that build hills, bees that build hives, and Borg that assimilate?
Compare the cultural production of Russia vs. China. I’ll just cover literature and playwriting.
- Alexander Sumarokov
- Gavrila Derzhavin
- Denis Fonvizin
- Alexander Radishchev
- Nikolay Novikov
- Nikolay Karamzin
- Ivan Krylov
- Vasily Zhukovsky
- Alexander Griboyedov
- Alexander Pushkin
- Fyodor Tyutchev
- Nikolai Gogol
- Alexander Herzen
- Ivan Goncharov
- Mikhail Lermontov
- Alexander Sukhovo-Kobylin
- A. K. Tolstoy
- Ivan Turgenev
- Afanasy Fet
- Nikolai Nekrasov
- Fyodor Dostoyevsky
- Alexander Ostrovsky
- Mikhail Saltykov-Schedrin
- Leo Tolstoy
- Nikolai Leskov
- Anton Chekhov
- Aleksandr Kuprin
- Zinaida Gippius
- Leonid Andreyev
- Fyodor Sologub
- Valery Bryusov
- Alexander Blok
- Marina Tsvetaeva
- Sergei Yesenin
- Velemir Khlebnikov
- Boris Pasternak
- Maxim Gorky
- Ivan Bunin
- Andrey Bely
- Vladimir Mayakovsky
- Anna Akhmatova
- Osip Mandelstam
- Yevgeny Zamyatin
- Mikhail Bulgakov
- Vladimir Nabokov
- Andrei Platonov
- Varlam Shalamov
- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
- Vasily Aksyonov
- Joseph Brodsky
To name just a few. There are more. Russia has probably the deepest literary history in our world history, so deep they choose that to highlight in the opening ceremonies of the 2014 Winter Games in Sochi. I watched that with delight and thought it an excellent celebration of Russian culture going way back.
China has a literary history too. But who that’s not Chinese know fuck all about it? Perhaps a few. If you scan down the list of Russians, my guess is that a lot of people around the world would recognize 5-10 names.
Who hasn’t read some Dostoyevsky? Solzhenitsyn? Nabokov? Tolstoy? Chekhov?
…But if you’re born Russian—even a Russian cat—you’re now cancelled worldwide because of where you happened to be born.
It is perhaps the greatest puerile injustice I have ever seen in my life. Before I get more into that, here’s more laughable cancelling. Expect McDonald’s to pull up chocks any day now.
Luxury brands halt sales in Russia: Gucci, Louis Vuitton, Chanel, and Cartier have ceased operations in the country amid the Ukrainian conflict.
A number of major luxury brands announced late on Friday that they would be closing their stores and halting their operations in Russia. They cited logistical difficulties and concern for staff safety amid the invasion of Ukraine.
The Kering Group said it would be temporarily shuttering its boutiques, including those of Gucci, Yves Saint Laurent, and Balenciaga, “due to growing concerns regarding the current situation in Europe.”
LVMH, the world’s biggest luxury company by sales, with a stable of more than 75 brands, including Christian Dior, Louis Vuitton and Moёt, released a statement to the fashion news outlet WWD. It said its stores would be temporarily closed in Russia from Sunday.
RT News
I’ve not linked it directly. Telegram banned RT yesterday, because Russian. I’ve had RT News as a feed source for a while. It’s Russian. it’s also the most objective news source in all my feeds. Fox “News” is laughable by comparison and all the others, a complete joke. Actually, if you want to see what some objective journalism looks like, check out RT. Also Al Jazeera; at times, at least.
Vacuums will be filled.
Way back at the advent of social media, performative moral exhibitionism existed a little bit. As everyone adopted social media—lured in by cat videos, hookups, and oh my balls—there arose an opportunity to morally condemn strangers across the world in a way that was psychologically satisfying. The entire world saw your moral righteousness and surely got a taste of how upright and virtuous you are. A cut above even the most vaulted cuts above.
The world didn’t materially change. Covid did squat and anyone with an honest brain knows that. A respiratory virus? Yawn. What changed was that every stupid fucking thought in the walnut now goes around the world to every other stupid fucking walnut; and then, if enough stupid fucking walnuts like and share, it attains the status of Oracle. That goes for all the blue checks, too. Especially the blue checks.
So what comes to pass is not another real crisis—let Russia and Ukraine, and neighbors, sort it out—but another opportunity for a world exposed as mostly walnut brains to keep doing whatever dose it is that dopamine satisfies for a walnut brain. Seems to be damn little, judging by hours spent online to perform moral exhibisionism.
When I see Russian expat folk with adorable children down at our local 7 Eleven unable to check out because the electrons in their cards are Russian, and the ATMs don’t work either, then I get really perturbed—regardless that I don’t socialize with them. Russians generally socialize only with other Russians. Not my way. Their absolute right.
The real harm of Covid was that real, innocent folk in the billions all over the world got hurt bad for the financial benefit and enhanced power of elites, corporations, politicians, and institutions. It was cheered on predominantly by the left around the world.
Now that that is gloriously crashing down with lies and criminality being exposed daily, it’s time for the same left to have a new outlet for their performative moral exhibitionism, and that shifts the burden from being someone who doesn’t want to be masked, doesn’t want to be under house arrest, and doesn’t want to have an experimental drug injected into them…onto anyone born in Russia, with only a few dispensations for Russians who condemn their homeland.
What fucking world is being crafted here, and when does it finally come for you?
WHAT IT'S ABOUT AND HOW IT WORKS
Free The Animal is an eclectic writing project about everything since November 2003. 23 years, 5,500 posts, 5 million words.
It's a paid membership blog. Most posts are free and public, but only paid members can comment. What determines whether it's free or paid is when I publish. Monday through Friday, free and public. Saturday and Sunday, for paid members. That's it. Membership info here.

Good insights.
I went to church Sunday and heard the preacher talk about fasting during Lent. This is an evangelical church so Lent is not necessarily a familiar concept to most. About Jesus spending 40 days fasting in the wilderness representing 40 years in the wilderness, going alone to the physical brink before being tempted.
I go there with my husband. I am on walkabout from christianity and have been for maybe a decade, but I am thoroughly marinated in it. My father was a preacher’s kid. My husband is a preacher’s kid. I was a missionary in my youth. My sisters run a mentoring ministry to single women in Texas. I find some things at church offensive to me, but church people are my people. My dysfunctional family. I don’t sing. I don’t take communion. I listen, observe. Socialize a little.
This is Montana, which (mostly) unmasked pretty early compared to many places. When churches were able to start meeting again in person during the “crisis”, this church was the first place I went where people seemed relaxed and unafraid of certain death. Unmasked, hugging and happy to see each other after so much time apart. It was like getting oxygen.
So this Sunday the preacher said if you can’t fast from food for physical reasons, you can fast from screens, or something else, and spend time in prayer. Now I don’t really pray like that anymore, as in bouncing a message off a satellite (God out there) to help someone I am near. But I do believe in our urge to extend and verbalize our wish to help and bless other humans in their trouble. Or verbalize our own need for help and insight (yes I think out loud a lot). And so when I am struggling say with an extreme difficulty, I ask people of faith to pray for me. And it makes me feel better knowing their hearts are with me, like being hugged when you are not in the same room.
I had already decided not long ago to break myself from obsessively checking my phone and relying on it so much. I’ve been leaving it at home more. Writing things down on paper when I need to go somewhere instead of using it for directions. Trying to become fully, mentally present for a change. Watch people, stand in line and have conversations. I quit using the drive through, I go into the bank or the coffee shop so I interact face to face and look people in the eyes. Instead of letting my phone and whatever research tidbit I was chasing take me somewhere else. And if my family feels the need to obsessively check in on me while I am gone, they are out of luck. I left a note at home. I’ll be back when I get back. A line from a novel I like.
No more will I sit in a restaurant with a tv before my face, and another the other side before my husband’s face. It’s hypnotic, when you can’t tear your eyes away to have a conversation. Crisis on constant repeat, reinforcement everywhere you go. I’m a visual person and rather sensitive, and I don’t watch horror movies for the same reason. The assault on my psyche. It’s unhealthy never to quiet your mind. And the digital highway yall, it’s broad. It looks to me like a road that leads to destruction. I decided to narrow down and be intentional about the way I use it. I took myself off the Amazon account, I don’t want to buy from there unless absolutely necessary. I’ve been stopping in at the local used bookstores. Much more fun.
My husband sold a tent yesterday using Craigslist. I decided to deliver it to the guy, since my husband was going skiing with a friend and I was planning to hole up in a coffee shop to read a book. The guy who bought the tent was working at the laundromat he owns. After he handed me the cash and had me count it, we ended up having a two hour conversation. We had so much in common, so much to talk about. He’s young, married with little kids. Said he bought the place just before covid hit and it ended up being like a community center, one of the few places people could gather, lots of kids and folks. You never know where you’ll find inspiration and encouragement, but I found it at the laundromat.
Very sorry to hear your observations of your Russian neighbors at 7-11. Maybe the next currency to invest in is cigarettes. finance-watch.org/the-perfect-draw-when-cigarettes-became-a-war-camp-currency/
I loved reading your post. I happen to be a rare breed, I don’t own a cell phone. I use the phone on my computer if I need a phone at all. I don’t have much money anyway and I chose it this way as I find it pretty abhorrent that people live in luxury and think about vacations and things, whilst so many people have nothing, at the risk of performing moral exhibitionism! Our system is so convoluted I don’t know where to start, but this is what I study and I have found cracks that we can grow through. One biggie is this system has made us think in terms of penalty only and the ones who do good get nothing. So there is no encouragement for better performance. Desires need to have impetus otherwise, why bother? This encompasses all our actions. Yet we pay no heed to it. Why is there no value for doing the right things? The things that generate satisfaction, function and needs? Why do we pay little concern for beauty when it may be the most important thing. I’m not talking about Hollywood beauty…all the ideas that have infected us have turned our species against itself. How can we turn it back around? I think there is one answer that applies uniformly – talking, dialogue, conversation, debate. Using the human voice instrument in harmony with the mind! Wow, no wonder they want to control us!
Really great stuff Ralna. Had to read it twice it’s so good. You’re really on the path back to rediscovering humanity and in-person contact and conversation.
I had a 2-hr convo with a neighbor Brit expat in the pool yesterday. So much in common and then about an hour in, turns out we both know all the same other expats in the area. How in the world can social media compete with that.
I liked this:
“Now I don’t really pray like that anymore, as in bouncing a message off a satellite (God out there) to help someone I am near.”
There’s this meme out there of someone bowing in prayer and the caption reads: “Prayer, literally the least you can do.” In terms of right/religious and left attitudes, it’s the difference between preparing a dinner and knocking at the door of a friend or family in need to serve it up, and calling in Uber Eats for them.
Again, fantastic comment.
Wow man, Wow~! I love this article. Those two terms you used “moral condemnation” and “performative moral exhibitionism” is what we have been seeing in the last two years. How did we escape the psychosis? There are so few who have. I’d like to start dialogues going further, taking this further, talking to people who are awake to these psychological contortions. We hold dialogues every Friday night and anyone is invited. If you want to say something then here is the place to do it – no moderation! Sovereigns speaking with sovereigns! What a breath of fresh air. Just ask for the meeting room link if you’re interested, if anyone is interested. Talking, dialoguing is the surest way we can dissolve the stricture of whatever this energy is. I am familiar already but read it again and it never ceases to confound me how they did it, how the Khazarian Mafia convinced the world. They of course had a multi-pronged platform but money is the main way. We should be getting off their money – that is the thing that will free us. We of course have to do it intelligently. This game is amazing isn’t it! How did Bill Hicks know back then?
Bottom line: thank you for a most absorbing article, one of the best I could read anywhere. You put the joy into reading. Keep us giggling! Bravo!
I link two here to illustrate how pervasive this energy is. Yet with a little knowledge and dialogue, we can extinguish its need to exist.
Khazarian Mafia:
geopolitics.co/2015/03/11/hidden-history-of-the-incredibly-evil-khazarian-mafia/?fbclid=IwAR13HRYGHZ…
And an obscure researcher Matthew Delooze who influenced David Icke speaking about the “dark energies” ways of luring humans to them harvesting our energy (concerts, etc) Mind blowing stuff. This one talks about the ferris wheels popping up in many cities. youtube.com/watch?v=ANBAz4_22b8
Finally!
montreal.ctvnews.ca/quebec-diner-drops-poutine-from-the-menu-the-word-not-the-dish-to-denounce-putin…
Whew, that was close!
Richard great article as ever,
It looks like the PRC government have hung any of their people that reside in Ukraine out to dry. Maybe they expected it to be a walkover for Russian forces so instead of advising their fellow Borg to leave they simply told them to stay put and place a PRC flag in their windows and vehicles.
Also some comments on Chinese social media regarding Ukrainian women went discovered by Ukraine media and has lead to some Chinese having to claim they are Japanese when challenged!
Video by Winston Sterzal vlogger, one time expat in China and motorcycle tourist.
youtu.be/kxprOQuVamE
Really enjoying the Russia/Ukraine and expat life articles!
Chris
Good video in terms of mocking abject nationalism, but it’s clear he’s drunk the kool aid for Ukraine.
Yeah I saw a Tucker Carlson piece where he stated it’s the third mass formation psychosis event in the US in two years. In the UK we can also add Brexit to the mix.
Zelensky made a (highly plagiarised) speech to the UK Parliament yesterday by video and I’m sure some of those there and in the MSM were disappointed there were no loaves and fish descending from the sky..
None of them wants to be the first to stop clapping.
twitter.com/JuliaHB1/status/1501244350642204675?s=20&t=t5x67bov94aItKrwu7CTAA
Was it this one?
youtu.be/1PC7DzTRS7A
I wonder if we have a problem with “mass formations” or are all these formations really just fundamentalist religo-leftism in practice? I’m starting to think the latter, which is a stickier and longer-term problem than Desmet’s mass formations.
Great article, thank you Richard.
I think it’s all manifestations of the same basic thing and my hunch is that while humans are social animals, we evolved in small tribes and bands with clear hierarchies and roles.
One of my favorite sayings is that “it does not scale.” So, for example, yea, maybe you can effectively do universale health in homogenous small societies like Scandinavia and Japan, but does that work in a nation of cats, like the USA?
So, relating that, how does a valid cry out of potential danger in a tribe of 100 scale to billions of people all over the world holding a broadcast center in their hand?
Check out Gustave Le Bon.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustave_Le_Bon
goodreads.com/book/show/35792.The_Crowd_Extraordinary_Popular_Delusions_the_Madness_of_Crowds
That’s it. I saw it from two separate links the second half first..
I shared it on Telegram and to a short list of family last night saying it might be the best Tucker ever. I watched it twice, may watch again since it’s in an open tab.